FSA launches long-awaited raw milk review – an informed choice?

3 February 2014 - 2:23pm -- Gerry Danby
Hook & Son - raw milk fresh from the farm direct to your door

Hook and Son Est. 1959. Raw milk fresh from the farm, direct to your door.

The Food Standards Agency (FSA) has announced the public consultation stage following a policy review of sales of raw drinking milk. The consultation pack which accompanied the announcement last Thursday, 30 January, extends to 191 pages[1] of detailed information and sets out four options for the future. The good news is that the FSA has expressed a preference for continuing raw milk sales under the fourth of the following four options:

Option 1: Do nothing

Option 2: All milk to be pasteurised prior to sale

Option 3: Allow sales of raw drinking milk from all outlets

Option 4: Introduce measures to harmonise and clarify current controls.

In short, in a choice between the status quo, either extreme and somewhere in the middle, a whisker away from the status quo it is the last of these which is preferred by the FSA at this stage. The law as it stands says that sales can only be direct from the farm to the final consumer which under Option 4 would mean:

  • Raw drinking milk from cows: No change to current domestic legal restrictions, but the FSA to publish guidance clarifying the intention of the law.
  • Raw drinking milk from other species: Introduce same sales restrictions as for cows’ milk through legislation or a voluntary code of practice.
  • Labelling: Amended mandatory health warning consistent across England, Wales and Northern Ireland and all species.
  • Other routes of sale: Direct from farm, farmers’ markets and direct online internet sales - no change.

Due credit to the FSA for stating a clear preference at the outset and one which sees a future for the continued supply of raw drinking milk. No doubt the FSA has been heavily influenced by the complete absence of any evidence pointing to the need for substantive change, but nonetheless welcome while acknowledging it is only a preliminary view.[2]

Evidence of risk to health

The evidence speaks for itself. There have been no reported outbreaks of illness associated with raw drinking milk in the UK since 2002 as illustrated in the table below:

 

Number of reported outbreaks associated with Raw Drinking Milk (RDM) and Cream in England & Wales, Scotland and NI between 1980 and 2011

Furthermore, several other factors should be noted, including:

  • The outbreaks in the 1990s and early 2000s were very small in comparison to earlier outbreaks.[3]
  • National surveillance data for VTEC (pathogenic E. coli) infection reveals that the overwhelming majority of cases of VTEC infection (97-99%) do not report raw milk consumption. The small number which do (1-3% or 51 out of 2,384 cases in England) also report exposure to other sources of infection. In short, raw milk does not cause significant numbers of cases of VTEC illness in the UK.[4]
  • The latest surveillance data for raw drinking milk is from surveys carried out between 1995 and 1999 indicated Campylobacter spp, E. coli O157, Salmonella spp and L. monocytogenes present in up to 2, 0.5, 0.5 and 3% of samples respectively. If still present at these levels it would support the view that the likelihood of exposure to pathogens is low. It is not unusual for large surveys of ready to eat foods to find occasional presence of pathogens similar to these levels.[5]

Shortcomings in the consultation

Where the consultation pack falls short, however, is in at least two significant respects. First, it fails to establish a core principle or principles guiding the implementation of the legislation and, second, provides no comparative assessment of risk associated with raw milk as against other foods.

Integrity of the food chain

The first follows from a reading of the legislation (The Food Safety and Hygiene (England) Regulations 2013, Schedule 6) which makes it clear that what it seeks to protect is the integrity of the food chain from farmer to consumer in a very direct way. The farmer retains ownership and control over the milk, and so remains responsible for milk quality, from its source in the production unit until delivered into the hands of the consumer. A food chain can get no shorter or have greater integrity.

The one exception provided for in the regulations covers a person operating a milk round who takes delivery of milk in sealed containers.

So rather than try and provide for all conceivable situations, better to establish principles and illustrate with some examples. The FSA would be quick to point out that it is the courts which are the final arbiters of what is and is not lawful and they are adept at extracting the principles and purpose of legislation and applying them in a contemporary setting as routes to market evolve and new ones emerge. This would provide a rationale and a framework which all could understand, accept and work within.

The failure to establish clear principles is likely to lead to continuing confusions of the sort which the FSA aims to avoid and which have been written about on this blog elsewhere.

Raw milk is not a high risk food

The second significant shortcoming is that little or no information is provided about where raw milk stands as, for want of a better description, a ‘risky food’. The comparison is always made with pasteurised milk which is an inherently safe product. If the risk of contracting an infection from pasteurised milk is very small, even a 100% (purely for the sake of argument since the true figure is not known) increase on that level of risk remains very small. In order to make an informed choice it is necessary to get things into perspective, how does raw milk rank against a range of foods we eat?

In May last year Canadian researcher Nadine Ijaz, in a presentation made to the British Colombia Centre for Disease Control, demonstrated how inappropriate evidence has long been mistakenly used to affirm the myth that raw milk is a high risk food. The conclusion?

“… public health bodies should now update their policies and informational materials to reflect the most high-quality evidence, which characterizes this risk as low.”

In the US, as Ijaz points out, green leafy vegetables are the most frequent cause of foodborne illness.   

77% support continued raw milk sales

Meanwhile, it is encouraging to observe, from survey data commissioned by the FSA, that 77% of those surveyed supported the continued sales of raw drinking milk, while 20% expressed interest in buying or consuming raw milk and 3% do so regularly.

The consultation pack covers much more to be explored in the coming weeks, not least raw milk controls over milk from species other than cows – goats, sheep and buffalo, the evidence for reported health benefits and how small dairy farms could be supported.

This is an important consultation, not simply for the future availability of raw milk, but the whole question of consumer choice in the food we eat. Let this not be a missed opportunity – make your voice heard!

Meanwhile, feel free to post your comments and questions below. The consultation closes 30 April 2014.

 

Details of the consultation can be found here: Impact Assessment on the review of the controls governing the sale and marketing of unpasteurised, or raw drinking milk and raw cream (RDM) in England

There is more information in the Artisan Food Law Library on the law relating to raw milk here: Dairy: Raw Drinking Milk

Photo: © @hookandson www.hookandson.co.uk Est. 1959. Raw milk fresh from the farm, direct to your door.




[1] Food Standards Agency, Impact Assessment on the review of the controls governing the sale and marketing of unpasteurised, or raw drinking milk and raw cream (RDM) in England, 30 January 2014

[2] FSA (2014), p4, para 10

[3] FSA (2014), p10, para 18

[4] FSA (2014), Annex B, p19, para 53 to 54

[5] FSA (2014), p20, para 56

 

Comments

Submitted by Simon Fairlie (not verified) on

The biggest flaw in it is that it doesn't give the option of allowing farmers to sell raw milk from their own machines in shopping centres etc, which is standard practice on the continent.

Submitted by Gerry Danby on

 

Hi Simon

You have a point here which is worth exploring. The FSA’s position on vending machines is very unclear and confused. I explored some of these issues when the FSA dropped the prosecution against Steve Hook (http://www.artisanfoodlaw.co.uk/blog/nutrition-and-health/food-standards-agency-abandons-raw-milk-prosecution-%E2%80%93-did-penny-finally) and they are worth pursuing.

What matters is the integrity of the food chain from farmer direct to consumer, and they come no shorter than that. If this can be established, the means taken – farmers’ market, internet sales, vending machine etc. – has little significance, the purpose of the legislation has been met. Hope you and many more make this point.

Gerry 

Submitted by Evan (not verified) on

Attractive ѕection of content. I just stumbled upon yoᥙr
site and in accession capital tߋ assert that Ӏ get aϲtually enjoyed account
ʏoսr blog posts. Ꭺnyway I ѡill be subscribing to yоur augment and even I achievement уou access consistently rapidly.

My web-site; <a href="https://guongbi.com/">guong navado</a>

Submitted by Noe (not verified) on

Just wish to say your article is as astounding. The clarity to your
put up is simply cool and that i could think you're knowledgeable on this subject.
Well with your permission let me to snatch your RSS feed to keep updated
with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the
rewarding work.

My website :: call girls in islamabad - http://En.recidemia.com/That%E2%80%99s_Wherever_Our_Pakistani_Escorts_Co...

Submitted by Rashad (not verified) on

best canadian mail order pharmacies
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/viagra-cheap-to-buy-1.html">cuanto dura el efecto de una cialis de 10 mg</a>
canada drugs
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/how-to-buy-cialis-online-safely-1.html">get viagra from canada</a>
canadian <a href="http://kizatokj.com/buy-cialis-england.html">where can i buy viagra in chicago</a>
<a href="http://quhjkamymygozi.com/cheap-generic-viagra-online-uk.html">viagra online test</a>
List of Safe Online Pharmacies
<a href="http://qopoxjtomi.com/best-place-order-levitra.html">can you buy viagra over internet</a>
fda approved canadian online pharmacies
<a href="http://kevjzy-zi.com/cheapest-generic-cialis-no-prescription-2.html">che... price for viagra online</a>
online pharmacies in usa
<a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/cheap-generic-viagra-overnight-delivery-1.html">buy viagra uk sites</a>
canada pharmacy online
<a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/order-cialis-online.html">cialis 20 mg directions for use</a>
canadian drugs
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/buy-viagra.html">cheap-kamagra-supplier.com</a>
lloyds pharmacy online

Submitted by Caitlin (not verified) on

canadian pharmacy reviews
legal to order viagra online - http://kizatokj.com/buy-cialis-ebay.html
priceline pharmacy
viagra sale america - http://nyfotjva.com/buy-cheap-cialis-line.html
buy medication without an rx
legit site to buy viagra - http://hiqe-topj.com/can-buy-viagra-uk.html
canada pharmacy online
365pills.com viagra - http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/buy-viagra.html
online pharmacies how to get viagra in bangkok - http://kizatokj.com/viagra-women-sale-uk.html usa
cialis online best place buy - http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/buy-cialis-from-europe-1.html
canadian online rx
buy viagra 25 mg - http://hiqe-topj.com/viagra-buy-india.html
Top Rated Online Canadian Pharmacies
can buy viagra mexico - http://qopoxjtomi.com/order-viagra-trial.html
Canadian Online Pharmacy
viagra pills for sale uk - http://kizatokj.com/safe-place-to-buy-cialis.html
Safe Canadian Online Pharmacies

Submitted by Louella (not verified) on

Thanks for one's marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you are
a great author.I will make certain to bookmark your blog and
definitely will come back down the road. I want to encourage one to continue your
great job, have a nice evening!

My blog ... <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zqnbqa8H9U">best ejaculating dildo</a>

Submitted by Judson (not verified) on

canadian pharmacies
harga cialis 80 mg - http://rjnita-duqiky.com/what-cialis-pills-look-like.html
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
cialis viagra levitra sale - http://momjtu-wiro.com/is-it-legal-to-order-viagra-from-canadian.html
canadian viagra
price viagra walmart - http://kevjzy-zi.com/buy-viagra-from-usa.html
prescription drugs online without
where do we get viagra in bangalore - http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/cheap-cialis-in-the-usa.html
canadian pharmacy
annual sale viagra - http://kizatokj.com/buy-cialis-england.html
Trusted Online Pharmacies
order viagra with no prescription online - http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/buy-cialis-new-zealand.html
prescription drugs online without doctor
easiest way to get viagra - http://momjtu-wiro.com/is-it-legal-to-order-viagra-from-canadian.html
canadian online pharmacy
prix vente cialis 5 mg - http://qjdekonu.com/cialis-super-active-for-sale.html
canadian pharmacy reviews

Feel free to visit my web-site ... kamagra cheap uk - http://hiqe-topj.com/buy-cialis-today-1.html

Submitted by Johnette (not verified) on

canadian pharmacies
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/buy-cialis-online-generic.html">cheapest super viagra</a>
best canadian mail order pharmacies
<a href="http://bixesuma-navetu.com/how-cheap-is-viagra.html">cheapest generic levitra</a>
canadian pharmacies
<a href="http://quhjkamymygozi.com/buy-cialis-no-prescription-in-uk-1.html">does viagra pill work</a>
pharmacy direct
<a href="http://qopoxjtomi.com/where-to-order-viagra-online-1.html">generic viagra from ranbaxy</a>
canadian online pharmacies
<a href="http://kevjzy-zi.com/cheap-discount-viagra.html">cheap viagra forum</a>
drugstore online
<a href="http://bysorjdoxole.com/cheapest-cialis-and-viagra.html">where can i buy viagra for the brain</a>
aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
<a href="http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/buy-viagra-online-new-york.html">when to take 10mg cialis</a>
Safe Canadian Online Pharmacies
<a href="http://kizatokj.com/order-cialis-australia.html">generic cialis 10mg</a>
northwestpharmacy

Review my blog ... <a href="http://kyhise-defanj.com/buy-levitra-in-singapore-1.html">anybody tried generic viagra</a>

Submitted by Julianne (not verified) on

You can certainly see your skills in the work you write.
The sector hopes for even more passionate writers like you who are not
afraid to say how they believe. All the time go after your heart.

Visit my web site :: boracay hotels - http://Boracayhotels.co/

Submitted by Dave (not verified) on

Walgreens Pharmacy
<a href="http://hiqe-topj.com/buy-viagra-paypal.html">is selling viagra online illegal</a>
canadian pharmacy online
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/order-cialis-no-prescription-canada.html">buy real viagra online</a>
Legitimate Canadian Mail Order Pharmacies
<a href="http://hiqe-topj.com/viagra-sale-brisbane-1.html">can you cut a 100mg viagra in half</a>
pharmacy direct
<a href="http://hiqe-topj.com/viagra-sale-forum.html">buy viagra puerto vallarta</a>
epharmacy
<a href="http://bysorjdoxole.com/original-cialis-pills.html">comprare viagra generico in farmacia</a>
epharmacy
<a href="http://kizatokj.com/cheap-viagra-cialis-online.html">how to use tadalafil tablets</a>
prescription drugs online without
<a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/order-cialis-online-in-canada.html">does viagra come in generic form</a>
canadian online pharmacy
<a href="http://nyfotjva.com/cialis-pills-what-are-for-1.html">buy daily dose cialis</a>
canadian pharmacy reviews

Feel free to surf to my site :: <a href="http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/cheap-cialis-thailand-1.html">can buy cialis australia</a>

Submitted by Lurlene (not verified) on

Top Rated Online Canadian Pharmacies
buy cheap viagra mastercard - http://quhjkamymygozi.com/cheapest-price-on-cialis.html
canadian online rx
generic cialis manufacturer - http://bixesuma-navetu.com/order-viagra-tesco.html
viagra canada
viagra sale over counter uk - http://qopoxjtomi.com/order-viagra-by-phone.html
canadian pharmacy
do i need a prescription to buy viagra online - http://qjdekonu.com/cheapest-viagra-super-force-2.html
prescription drugs online without
how to buy cialis in japan - http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/cheap-generic-viagra-in-uk.html
prescription drugs online without doctor
viagra discount coupon - http://momjtu-wiro.com/where-is-the-best-place-to-buy-cialis.html
prescriptions online
buy sildenafil in the uk - http://bysorjdoxole.com/viagra-buy-in-london.html
List of Safe Online Pharmacies
yohimbe and cialis together - http://nyfotjva.com/buy-viagra-costa-rica.html
lloyds pharmacy online

Feel free to visit my web site ... erofast sildenafil 50
mg bula - http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/buy-viagra-usa-online.html

Submitted by Horacio (not verified) on

canada pharmacies online prescriptions
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/is-the-viagra-you-buy-online-real.html">viagra how to get</a>
<a href="http://bysorjdoxole.com/best-place-to-order-cialis.html">can you take lexapro and viagra together</a> canada
<a href="http://hiqe-topj.com/cialis-for-sale-2.html">can u buy viagra over the counter</a>
canadian pharmacy
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/generic-levitra-cheap.html">using trimix and cialis together</a>
best canadian mail order pharmacies
<a href="http://cexyluze.com/taking-2-cialis-pills.html">where to order cialis online safe</a>
epharmacy
<a href="http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/cheap-viagra-canadian-pharmacy.html">can you buy generic viagra store</a>
online pharmacy
<a href="http://quhjkamymygozi.com/cheap-cialis-australia-1.html">happens if you take cialis viagra together</a>
prescriptions online
<a href="http://hiqe-topj.com/buy-levitra-uk.html">genericos de sildenafil</a>
northwest pharmacy canada
<a href="http://hokevy-nu-zy.com/viagra-cheap-to-buy.html">what is the generic viagra</a>
discount pharmacy

Submitted by Leta (not verified) on

Thanks for the marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you can be a great
author. I will sex toys that make you squirt - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zqnbqa8H9U sure to bookmark your blog and will come back in the future.

I want to encourage continue your great work, have a nice
morning!

Submitted by Alberto (not verified) on

I don't know if it's just me or if perhaps everyone else experiencing issues
with your site. It appears as though some of the
written text in your content are running off the screen. Can somebody else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well?
This may be a issue with my web browser because I've had this happen before.
Kudos

my web site; <a href="http://Dfund.net/?p=556340">angeles city bars</a>

Submitted by Perry (not verified) on

Hi! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords
but I'm not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
Kudos!

my web page: Boracay - http://Boracayhotels.co/

Submitted by Scarlett (not verified) on

canada pharmacies online prescriptions
cialis 10mg - http://kizatokj.com/cheapest-way-to-get-cialis.html
prescription drugs online without
buy cialis online new zealand - http://quhjkamymygozi.com/where-to-order-levitra-online.html
canadian viagra
buy viagra boots chemist - http://qjdekonu.com/cialis-super-active-for-sale.html
canadian online pharmacies
viagra bestellen online - http://kizatokj.com/cheap-viagra-cialis-online.html
Safe Canadian Online Pharmacies
buying viagra in cabo - http://nyfotjva.com/want-buy-cheap-viagra.html
discount pharmacy
when is the generic for viagra available - http://rjnita-duqiky.com/viagra-sale-bristol.html
buy medication without an rx
online prescription viagra buy online - http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/cheap-generic-levitra-india.html
canadian pharmacy
viagra from india online - http://quhjkamymygozi.com/cheapest-brand-cialis-online.html
pharmacy online

my blog cialis generico 24 horas - http://hiqe-topj.com/cialis-on-sale.html

Submitted by Dwayne (not verified) on

Walgreens Pharmacy
<a href="http://qopoxjtomi.com/cheapviagratabletscom.html">is it legal to buy generic cialis</a>
canadian pharmacies online
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/viagra-super-force-100mg-100mg-pills.html">farm... genericos comprar cialis generico online tadalafil precio</a>
canadian online pharmacy
<a href="http://cexyluze.com/order-viagra-pills-online.html">order levitra cheap</a>
Online Drugstores
<a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/buy-cialis-online-in-usa-1.html">sildenafil buy online uk</a>
pharmacy online
<a href="http://cexyluze.com/generic-cialis-sale.html">genericos del viagra colombia</a>
canadian pharmacy online
<a href="http://kizatokj.com/member-php-buy-levitra.html">price tadalafil tablets</a>
canadian pharmacies
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/is-it-illegal-to-order-viagra-online.html">opinioni su cialis generico</a>
buy medication without an rx
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/viagra-sale-online.html">cheap viagra forum</a>
northwestpharmacy

Here is my web page: <a href="http://kyhise-defanj.com/cheapest-generic-levitra-online-1.html">can you take cialis and levitra together</a>

Submitted by Leesa (not verified) on

prescription drugs online without doctor
<a href="http://nyfotjva.com/cheap-levitra-pills-1.html">anyone order viagra online</a>
drugstore online
<a href="http://rjnita-duqiky.com/order-viagra-online-usa-1.html">price viagra 100mg india</a>
online pharmacies canada
<a href="http://nyfotjva.com/discount-cialis-and-viagra.html">viagra buy new zealand</a>
online pharmacies in usa
<a href="http://qopoxjtomi.com/member-php-buy-levitra.html">cialis for order</a>
canadian pharmacy online
<a href="http://momjtu-wiro.com/viagra-cheaporg.html">sildenafil online portugal</a>
pharmacy online
<a href="http://bixesuma-navetu.com/buy-cialis-and-levitra.html">can u take viagra and cialis together</a>
prescriptions online
<a href="http://quhjkamymygozi.com/buy-generic-viagra-new-zealand.html">cheap viagra 50mg</a>
Online Drugstores
<a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com">viagra generica en farmacias</a>
canadian pharmacy online

my site ... <a href="http://qjpecy-tj-wu.com/cialis-cheap-fast-delivery.html">will fda approved generic viagra</a>

Pages

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
2 + 4 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.